Can You Replace A Kitchen Sink Without Replacing the Countertop?

Matthew Mountain
by Matthew Mountain

The kitchen sink is one of the most important fixtures in the modern kitchen. It’s used for so many different things, and therefore it needs to be highly functional, sturdy, and spacious.

But kitchen sinks aren’t infallible, which means eventually a sink-related problem may warrant replacing the sink. Also, you may come to realize that the sink you have no longer serves you well, and in this instance, it’s likely you’ll want a replacement sink.

In either case, you’d have to remove the preexisting sink before a replacement sink can be put in, but is doing this feasible when the kitchen sink is attached to a countertop? In other words, will removing the kitchen sink from the countertop damage the countertop and thus require a countertop replacement as well? This question and several which relate to it are answered in this article.

Provided you’re careful, possess the right tools, and are equipped with the know-how, you can remove a sink without damaging the countertop. Both drop-in and undermount sinks can be removed without causing exterior or interior countertop damage. However, it’s best to have a professional execute removal so the countertop is not damaged. Proper sink removal will also make replacement easier.

Do You Need to Hire Sink Installers?

Get free, zero-commitment quotes from pro contractors near you.

Can You Replace a Kitchen Sink Without Replacing the Countertop?

In the majority of cases, it’s possible to remove a kitchen sink without damaging the countertop. However, this is not a DIY job, as a mistake here could be a costly one. For this reason, it’s best to let a professional handle sink replacement, as this way unnecessary damage is avoided and the replacement sink gets installed properly.

Keep in mind also that there are different sink styles. There are undermount sinks and drop-in sinks, and the type of sink you have plays a major role in determining how easy sink removal is going to be. But for the most part, whether you have an undermount or a drop-in sink, successful replacement can be achieved without damaging the countertop.

There are, however, instances where a sink is integrated into a countertop, and in this instance, it wouldn’t be feasible to replace the sink. You’d essentially be damaging the countertop to make way for another sink, and any replacement wouldn’t fit well in such an instance. Here’s what you need to know about replacing undermount and drop-in sinks.

Can an Undermount Sink Be Removed Without Damaging the Countertop?

Removing an undermount sink can be more difficult than removing a drop-in sink, and that’s mainly because of the adhesive under the sink that holds the basin in place. This adhesive, once solidified, is incredibly strong. The adhesive will need to be cut and ground in order for the undermount sink to be removed.

Undermount sinks are preferred by those who don’t want any sink showing above the countertop. And when no part of the sink is above the countertop, it should be easy to avoid damaging the countertop’s exterior. If you do happen to chip or scratch some countertop, it would be under the sink where it’s not noticeable.

Still, you don’t want to compromise the structural integrity of the countertop, as doing so could lead to the countertop being weaker over time. Again, to ensure an undermount sink is completely and properly removed, it’s best to get a professional who’s skilled and experienced to handle this work.

Can a Drop-In Sink Be Removed Without Damaging the Countertop?

Yes, a drop-in sink can be removed from a countertop without the countertop getting damaged. But there are some things you must keep in mind before you go to remove the sink.

First, you must find and remove the clamps which hold the sink in place. Keep in mind that if these clamps are removed, the sink may be prone to shifting. And if a shift occurs in the midst of replacement, this is when the countertop is likely to get damaged.

The clamps must be gone before the countertop comes up, because if they’re not removed beforehand, then the countertop will try to come up with the sink when you pull. Once the clamps are off, grab a putty knife so you can break the silicone seal that’s between the sink and the countertop.

If you’re having trouble with removing the silicone seal, grab a rubber mallet to make removal easier. The grit should also be removed as you go to ensure the countertop is not scratched. Once all the seal has been removed, push up on the sink and it should come right off. Either pull it up or push it from below.

What Tools Are Needed to Replace a Sink?

You may not need all the tools listed below. However, it’s good to have them all ready to go, as this way you’re not left looking for tools in the midst of a replacement.

  • Putty knife
  • Pipe wrench
  • Socket wrench
  • Rubber mallet

It’s also good to have some safety glasses and a mask. After all, you may be exposed to fine silicone grit, especially when working under the sink.

Can a Sink That’s Glued Down Be Removed From a Countertop?

A sink can be removed from a countertop even after it’s been glued on, but it’s during this part of the removal process that one has to be very careful not to damage the countertop. A putty or utility knife will be required, and depending on what kind of sealant is used, you may need something stronger to break the seal. For example, some sinks are held down by liquid nails, and in this case, a putty knife and rubber mallet will both be needed to break the seal.

Do You Need to Hire Sink Installers?

Get free, zero-commitment quotes from pro contractors near you.

Will Removing Sink Clamps Damage a Countertop?

If you were to remove the sink clamps and then proceed to use the sink as normal, the sink would probably shift at some point, which is likely to damage the countertop. For this reason, if the clamps are ever removed, you need to ensure they are back on tight before you resume using the sink.

Matthew Mountain
Matthew Mountain

Matt loves everything DIY. He has been learning and practicing different trades since he was a kid, and he's often the first one called when a friend or family member needs a helping hand at home. Matt loves to work with wood and stone, and landscaping is by far his most favorite pastime.

More by Matthew Mountain