Are ClosetMaid And Rubbermaid Wire Shelves Interchangeable?

Matthew Mountain
by Matthew Mountain
Living in a small apartment teaches one how to maximize available space, and space-savers young and old specifically like wire shelving because it’s affordable, easy-to-install, and incredibly efficient. But are

Living in a small apartment teaches one how to maximize available space, and space-savers young and old specifically like wire shelving because it’s affordable, easy-to-install, and incredibly efficient.

But are ClosetMaid and Rubbermaid shelves interchangeable? Such is the question this article answers, along with providing the pros and cons of both ClosetMaid and Rubbermaid shelving.

ClosetMaid and Rubbermaid shelves are interchangeable, which means ClosetMaid shelf supports and shelves can be used with Rubbermaid hangers and vice versa. ClosetMaid wire shelving is preferred for its sturdiness, whereas Rubbermaid wire shelving is ideal for those who want adjustable shelving. A lot of closets mix both products successfully. ClosetMaid products are more expensive than Rubbermaid ones.

Do You Need Room or Closet Organizers Installed?

Get free, zero-commitment quotes from pro contractors near you.

ClosetMaid Background

ClosetMaid is a Florida-based company that’s been manufacturing ventilated wire shelving since 1965. They are a leader in the home storage and organization industry, and their products are used in bedrooms, kitchens, family rooms, laundry rooms, home offices, and garages.

In short, ClosetMaid wire shelves can be applied wherever a person needs to store something, and ClosetMaid’s products are sold at home-improvement stores as well as online. When looking for ClosetMaid products, make sure you’re shopping with a dealer who’s authorized by them.

Pros and Cons of ClosetMaid Shelving

ClosetMaid wire shelving is good for a variety of reasons, but it does have its downsides too. The pros and cons of ClosetMaid wire shelving are discussed below, and one should consider these pros and cons in totality before installing ClosetMaid wire shelving.

Pro: Sturdy

ClosetMaid shelves are meant to be permanent, and this in part explains why they’re so sturdy. They’re made of industrial-grade steel and they’re finished with an epoxy coating. This coating makes them durable yet smooth, and it also ensures the wire shelving is impervious to rust, discoloration, and peeling.

Also, this kind of wire shelving doesn’t get sticky, and one won’t have to worry about chipping, corrosion, or chemicals degrading the shelving.

All these qualities make ClosetMaid wire shelving heavy-duty. Therefore, one can’t go wrong installing this kind of wire shelving in their garage. A ClosetMaid wire shelf will be able to hold a range of tools and appliances for years with no issues, and all that’s needed—as far as maintenance is concerned—is some occasional dusting.

Pro: Accessory-Friendly

ClosetMaid wire shelving is accessory-friendly, meaning one can easily fix a range of accessories to their wire shelving to make it even better. Here are some of the popular accessories:

  • Fabric hampers
  • Over-the-door tie & belt racks
  • Stacking shelves
  • Hanging Baskets
  • Two-tier shoe racks
  • Hardware drawers
  • Hanging shoe organizers

If you only stick to ClosetMaid storage solutions, chances are your closet storage will be more uniform and efficient. You can, however, swap out some ClosetMaid items for some RubberMaid ones, as these latter products provide virtually the same utility that the ClosetMaid products do.

Con: Limited Flexibility Once Installed

One downside of ClosetMaid wire shelving is that it’s not very flexible once it’s been installed. Therefore, if you like adjusting your shelving organization regularly, you should avoid getting ClosetMaid and instead use Rubbermaid wire shelving.

Or, of course, you can use the adjustable Rubbermaid pieces along with some ClosetMaid accessories, as most of these accessories can be fixed to a Rubbermaid wire shelf.

Con: Cutting the Shelves Yourself

Cutting the shelves yourself isn’t a downside in itself, but it’s listed as a con because most individuals don’t have the time, skill, or tools to cut shelving on their own. That’s no problem, of course, because one can get their shelving cut when they buy it. All that’s needed at the time of purchase is the measurements.

If, however, your measurements are off, then your shelving won’t come out right. A person who is skilled with cutting shelving will be able to fix problems if they arise, whereas one without this skill will be going back to the store often.

Rubbermaid Background

Rubbermaid has been in business since the 1920s, but they really began manufacturing plastic and rubber products post 1950. They patented a rubber bath mat, one that used suction cups, and this was their first breakout household product success.

For almost 100 years, the company has been manufacturing products that homeowner stand by, and these days their wire shelves are some of their most popular items.

Find out how to install Rubbermaid Fasttrack.

Pro: Easy to Install

One of the most appealing qualities of Rubbermaid wire shelving is that it’s easy to install. So if you’ve never installed closet shelving before, Rubbermaid wire shelving is for you. The shelving isn’t permanent, so there will be no worrying about serious mess-ups. If you get something wrong, simply remove the shelving and adjust things accordingly.

Con: Flimsy

One downside of Rubbermaid wire shelving is that it’s more flimsy, especially when compared to ClosetMaid or Elfa wire shelving. This doesn’t mean that Rubbermaid wire shelving won’t hold up as long as shelving that’s made by these other two manufacturers.

It does, however, mean that Rubbermaid isn’t heavy-duty like these other two brands, and therefore it’s incapable of holding heavy items.

Where Wire Shelves Go Best in Homes

Wire shelves go great in garages, pantries, linen closets, and bedrooms. They provide plenty of ventilation, so they’re valuable in areas where both air circulation and item invisibility are important. They also don’t warp when exposed to moisture for an extended period, meaning they can be used on the home’s exterior as well. Here’s more on where these are used best:

Garages

Wire shelves possess the strength of solid metal shelves without the weight, which means they can be used in garages to store tools, small appliances, and other things one may need for at-home work.

Pantries

Wire shelves are ideal in pantries because they ensure decent airflow. They are also good because they provide a lot of visibility, especially towards the back, where solid shelves would be indiscernible. The only downside of wire shelves in a pantry is that—should you spill something like rice—it may go through all the shelf grates and create a big mess.

Linen Closets

Wire shelves go great in linen closets too, mainly because baskets, fabric hampers, and plastic bins can be fixed to the shelves to provide versatile storage. Since these closets are often filled with a variety of linens, wire shelves work well, as they provide simple, first-rate organization along with the sturdiness to hold the heaviest stack of bedding.

Bedrooms

Wire shelves are used in bedrooms too, but you’ll rarely find these above a bed. After all, if an earthquake hits or something else which causes the shelves to shake, what’s being stored on them may fall off and break, hurt someone, or both.

With this in mind, it’s best to put wire shelves on either side of the bed, or in another spot where they’re visually appealing. On these shelves, decorative items, plants, knickknacks, and/or other important bedroom-related fixtures can be kept.

Do You Need Room or Closet Organizers Installed?

Get free, zero-commitment quotes from pro contractors near you.


Related Questions

Can Elfa products be used with ClosetMaid and Rubbermaid wire shelving?

Yes, though this isn’t common practice. Elfa wire shelving and accessories are top-quality, which means they wouldn’t really go well when combined with Rubbermaid products. A more reasonable combination is Elfa and ClosetMaid, but even here these two brands struggle with coinciding.


Is a shelf installation a DIY task?

It certainly can be, but you’ll need the right tools and skills to make this happen. If you don’t have these, it’s best to get in touch with a professional. This way, costly errors are avoided. You’ll also be able to ensure the shelving is exactly how you want it.

Related Articles

Matthew Mountain
Matthew Mountain

Matt loves everything DIY. He has been learning and practicing different trades since he was a kid, and he's often the first one called when a friend or family member needs a helping hand at home. Matt loves to work with wood and stone, and landscaping is by far his most favorite pastime.

More by Matthew Mountain

Next