Garage Floor Stain Vs. Epoxy: What Are The Major Differences?

Upgraded Home Team
by Upgraded Home Team

Creating a beautiful space in your garage is a wonderful option to update not only your home but also enhance the longevity and durability of your garage floor. Both garage floor stain and epoxy are excellent choices for your home, and both have a litany of desirable benefits that make each a superb choice.

While epoxy can certainly help repair your garage floor from minor chips and cracks, this garage floor coating is prone to chipping after about three years. Comparatively, garage floor stain is a permanent solution that penetrates the concrete but will require regular sealing to maintain the color and pattern. Both epoxy and garage floor stains are incredibly durable and will help protect the concrete garage floor, expanding your garage floor lifetime.

Many people choose garage floor stains because of the straightforward installation approach. Epoxy takes a little longer to dry, and an additional preparation step to etch the concrete floor is needed. With both garage floor stain and epoxy, you will have an unlimited range of colors, patterns, and styles to use to make your garage floor a truly original space.

Do You Need to Hire a Flooring Contractor?

Get free, zero-commitment quotes from pro contractors near you.

What is Epoxy?

Using garage floor epoxy is a way to add a new material that adheres to the concrete floor. Epoxy is a thermosetting resin that adheres to the concrete, which is easily brushed or rolled into place. The epoxy coat is a mix of polyamine and epoxide resin which adheres directly to the concrete through the necessary etching process. Combining these two chemicals in the epoxy helps strengthen the concrete floor and adds more durability.

What are the Benefits of Using Epoxy?

Epoxy Paint for a garage floor has several wonderful benefits that can help to enhance the durability of your floor while making it a beautiful part of your home. Some of the top benefits of using epoxy include:

  • Moisture Resistant – Using epoxy to coat your garage floor is a great way to make a moisture and stain-resistant finish. This feature means that your floor will be protected from spills and leaks. Plus, anything that falls on your floor can simply be wiped up with a cloth and soapy water.
  • Durable – Garage floors take a beating, but adding epoxy can make them even more durable. Not only can epoxy withstand heavy cars, but it can also survive heavy machinery and equipment. The epoxy coating can help protect against surface abrasions and cracks too.
  • Endless Designs – Epoxy coatings come in several colors, which allows you to personalize your space with any pattern or design you like. It is even possible to add a custom logo to your garage to create a uniquely your own space.
  • Great Repair – Epoxy can help repair a damaged or cracked garage floor. Not only does the epoxy look great, but it can help create an even and finished coating that will mask and cover any damage to your floor.
  • Quick Installation – Installing an epoxy floor is very quick and easy. The entire process can be done in a day with only a few days of drying time.

What Is the Process to Install Garage Floor Epoxy?

The process to install garage floor epoxy is complex but doable for the average DIY homeowner. You’ll want to ensure that the garage floor is clean and free of debris or contaminants. A cement etcher is used to create an uneven surface for the epoxy to adhere to. Once the etcher is dry, the epoxy is rolled on and allowed to cure. It is safe to wait about seven days until you fully drive vehicles over the new epoxy surface.

Is Epoxy Expensive?

Compared to other options in a residential garage, epoxy is one of the more affordable options. Depending on the type of epoxy you choose, you can expect to pay between $3 and $7 per square foot of garage space. Of course, you’ll also want to factor in any supplies that you’ll need to apply the epoxy.

What is Garage Floor Stain?

Staining your garage floor is a popular option for people who want a different look on their concrete slab. An acid penetrates the concrete and creates a chemical reaction with the lime in the concrete. The reaction makes a natural-looking color that varies depending on the age and type of concrete that is used on the floor. Garage floor acid stain is a great way to give your floors a new, attractive, yet natural look.

What are the Benefits of Using Floor Stain?

Compared to epoxy coatings for garage floors, stained garage floors have some amazing benefits, making them an attractive option for homeowners. Some of the benefits of using a floor stain in your garage include:

  • Durable – The stain works to penetrate the concrete, which makes a permanent color. This characteristic means the stain will be fade-resistant and stay true to the intended color. Compared to painting or epoxy coating, you never run a risk of having a floor stain chip away or peel off.
  • Endless Designs – Choosing a concrete stain allows you a range of options to choose between. You can have tiny hints of color, add accents and designs, and sometimes even include customized graphics. While some people like to keep their stain design simple, others want to make a unique and original design in their garage.
  • Eco-Friendly – While other flooring options may require replacement after a few years, staining your garage floors is a long-lasting option with minimal waste. This characteristic means that fewer resources are used in the staining process, and no waste is generated from this durable solution.

What Is the Process to Use Garage Floor Stain?

Comparatively, the process of using garage floor stain is much more straightforward than using epoxy. Simply clean the garage floor surface, removing any debris or possible contaminants. You’ll want to evenly roll the stain onto the concrete surface and allow it to dry. Most stains need about 48 hours to penetrate the concrete surface and dry fully. Then, simply seal the stain, and your garage floor is ready to use.

How Much Does Floor Stain Cost?

Floor stain for your garage floor is an economical solution that can transform the way your garage looks. Compared to other options, floor stain is one of the most affordable choices. Expect to pay between $2 and $4 per square foot for a concrete floor stain.

Of course, there is a great deal of price variation depending on the type of stain you choose. If significant preparation is required to get your garage floors ready for the stain, you can add high cost to the overall project.

How Long Will Epoxy Last?

Most homeowners will get about two or three years of use from an epoxy floor coating with heavy traffic. If you start to see signs of wear or chipping, reapplying another layer of epoxy may be necessary. With proper care, though, and routine cleaning, you may be able to extend the life of your epoxy floor without ongoing application.

How Long Does Floor Stain Last?

Because the floor stain permanently penetrates the concrete, your stained floor will last a lifetime. However, your stained concrete floor does require regular sealing with a solvent or a water-based acrylic sealer. The sealer helps to keep the color and stain properties intact, allowing your floor to last longer. Most sealers will last about 18 to 24 months before a new application is required.

Can I Drive Over Epoxy and Floor Stain?

Once the epoxy is rolled over the garage floor, you will eventually be able to drive on this solid and durable surface. However, there is a more extended waiting period until you can drive on the floor. Once the floor is prepared, and the epoxy rolled on, you’ll need to wait about five days until you can move a car onto the surface. After about four hours, the surface should be safe to walk on without damaging the application.

Do You Need to Hire a Flooring Contractor?

Get free, zero-commitment quotes from pro contractors near you.

Related Questions

Can I paint a garage floor with interior paint?

Regular interior paint comes in two types, latex acrylic paint or epoxy paint. Latex paint will be a cheaper option but will not last as long as epoxy paint. Choosing epoxy paint will not only last longer, but it will create a more durable bond with the concrete. While latex paint will be prone to chipping and scratching, epoxy paint will be chip-resistant, giving you a longer, more finished look in your garage.

Will epoxy help protect my garage floor?

Epoxy  is a very tough and durable material that can help protect your garage floor from staining, chips, and everyday wear and tear. Plus, adding epoxy to a garage floor is a great way to enhance the strength of your concrete. Because epoxy bonds to the concrete itself, you can drastically improve the overall PSI of the concrete through an epoxy coating process. In addition, epoxy is a great way to make your garage uniquely your own, with a range of color and pattern options available.

Upgraded Home Team
Upgraded Home Team

We are a team of passionate homeowners, home improvement pros, and DIY enthusiasts who enjoy sharing home improvement, housekeeping, decorating, and more with other homeowners! Whether you're looking for a step-by-step guide on fixing an appliance or the cost of installing a fence, we've here to help.

More by Upgraded Home Team