Belt Drive Vs Chain Drive Garage Door Opener: Which Is Best?
The sort of drive system for your garage door is something you don’t think about often while searching for garage door openers. However, you will notice subtle differences because belt drive openers are usually smoother than chain drive openers. For example, one may be quieter while the other may have more strength to lift heavier garage doors.
A belt drive garage door opener is ideal if you value convenience and easy maintenance. Belt drives are also quieter; however, they cost more than a chain drive. Chain drives are more affordable, durable, and stronger; they’re better for two-car garages or larger. A chain drive will also last an average of 15 years; five years longer than belt drives.
In this article, we will compare chain drive garage door openers to belt drive so that you can understand which is more ideal for your situation. Let’s get started!
How Do Chain and Belt Drives Work?
A chain drive is a mechanically driven system that transfers power from one location to another by using chains. Two or more sprockets, as well as the chain itself, make up a traditional chain drive. The holes in the chain links cover the sprocket teeth.
The chain that’s wrapped around the shaft’s sprocket revolves with the core mover. This transfers mechanical power to the drive wheels by applying mechanical force.
On the other hand, a belt transmits power among at least two pulleys in a belt drive. One pulley (the driving pulley) drives the belt, while the belt powers the other. Because the belt drive speed is often decreased, the smallest pulleys are used as the driving pulley.
Comparing Chain vs. Belt Garage Door Openers
There is quite a bit of difference when it comes to chain and belt drive garage door openers. Below, we will compare them on several aspects such as price, convenience, strength, and more.
Convenience: Chain vs. Belt
One concern is convenience, which depends on how easily the opener can be installed and maintained. Both of these openers can last for over ten years, but they require different upkeep.
Chain drives need to be lubricated on a regular basis, and they may need to be adjusted once in a while. A belt drive does not require any lubrication or adjustments except for the initial gear lubrication.
Therefore when it comes to convenience, a belt drive is the easiest to handle as there isn’t much to owning one. Simply make sure that it’s working correctly when you operate it and go on about your day.
Strength: Chain vs. Belt
The chain drives are stronger than belt drives, allowing them to move massive amounts of weight. If you have a two-car garage door, go for a chain drive.
Chain drives are powerful enough to lift a two- or three-car garage door with ease. On the other hand, a belt drive will have problems lifting heavy wooden garage doors or anything larger than a one-car garage door. While it’s possible the belt can handle the job, this puts too much stress on it, causing it to wear down quickly.
A belt drive system will suffice if you only have a one-car garage door. Nonetheless, belt drives have come a long way in terms of design. It is now possible to locate a belt drive that can operate on virtually any door. They are, however, difficult to come by, and they cost significantly more.
Pricing: Chain vs. Belt
A solid chain drive garage opener will not let you down when it comes to price. They’re low-cost and very dependable. Because they are widely available, your garage door is likely to come with a standard chain drive. You can expect to pay between $120 and $270 for a chain drive opener.
On the other hand, belt drives are more expensive upfront and cost between $180 and $350. However, they are a more cost-effective solution in the long run. Because the rubber belt is moved up and down by a trolley and not a chain, belt drives last about ten years, whereas chain drives last around 15 years but may last longer.
Noise: Chain vs. Belt
Nothing is worse than a garage door that you can’t open quietly, especially when you’re trying to sneak in the house without waking the family. This is why many people prefer a quieter garage door rather than one that comes crashing down every time you close it.
Chain drives are noisier than belt drives. As a result, chain drive openers are not suggested if you have a connected garage with a bedroom directly above it.
Metal on metal friction makes a lot of noise, which will disturb your family and the neighbors across the street. Instead of a chain drive device, you might want to use a rubber belt that draws the belt on a trolley.
Wi-Fi Capability: Chain vs. Belt
Some homeowners love the convenience of WiFi-operated garage door openers. This allows them to open their door remotely. So, if they’re on vacation, they can open the app to let their neighbor in to feed their animals, or whatever the situation may be.
The WiFi-capable openers are very handy as well for subletting your home. So, if you leave for half the year and rent your house out, you’ll be able to let them through the door in case they misplace the keys.
Some apps will notify you if your garage door has been open or shut. It provides a sense of security that homeowners love. The only catch is that you will have a better chance of getting a Wi-Fi capable garage door opener with belt drives instead of chain drives.
Durability: Which Type of Garage Door Opener Lasts Longer?
Belt drives do not last as long as chain drives, but they are still durable. Because chain drives are constructed of metal, they have an advantage. Chain lasts about 15 years, whereas belt drives last around 10.
A chain drive opener will usually have two gears and work in virtually any situation. On the other hand, belt drives can be finicky, especially if you live where there are massive amounts of rain. A belt does not function very well when it’s wet.
Belt drive openers, unlike chain drives, do not rust, but the chain drive still wins in terms of durability because it lasts longer and can withstand more stress. You might have to lubricate it more if you live in an area where moisture can pose a problem.
Speed: Which Garage Door Opener is Faster?
Garage door openers, both chain, and belt operate at a slow speed. The reason for this is that if they go too quickly, they may collide with anyone or anything in their path. Manufacturers take great care in designing garage door openers so that they pose no threat to humans or objects when in operation.
The majority of today’s drives move at a speed of 7 to 8 inches per second, leaving no room for unsafe speed. Belt door openers are smoother to use than chain drives, making them appear to move faster. When you open or close a chain drive garage door, it bounces up and down the rails.
Maintenance: Which One Is Easier to Maintain?
Garage door openers with belt drives are arguably easier to maintain than chain drives. However, a belt will stretch or reach its limit at some point, needing to be replaced. Check the belt for damage if you hear loud grinding or squeaking noises while the garage door is opening.
Before the initial installation, you will need to grease the internal components. Whether belt-driven or not, internal gears must be oiled to avoid grinding and breaking down. Apart from that, you only need to check the belt now and then to ensure that the balance is correct, the tension is proper, and everything is still secure.
Potential Drawbacks of Belt Drive Garage Door Openers
As always, where there are benefits, there are also disadvantages. Here are some of the drawbacks when it comes to belt drives:
- Strength: Strength is a weakness for belt drive garage doors. These garage door openers can easily open a one-car garage, but they may struggle to raise heavier two-car garage doors.
- Lifespan: The belt drive opener may not last as long as the chain drive openers. As a result, you may need to change these belts more frequently; however, they come with a better warranty than others. As a result, it can be both advantageous and disadvantageous.
- Price: The belt drive garage door opener costs slightly more than others but always includes a warranty. You will need to consider your situation to see if paying that extra cost is worth it for you.
Potential Drawbacks of Chain Garage Door Openers
Chain-driven garage door openers also have a couple of disadvantages, which we’ve listed below:
- Noise: Many people believe they create excessive noise. A noisy garage door is an annoyance that some people would rather avoid. Because this system uses a chain drive, the constant metal-on-metal movement can produce unpleasant noises. This is especially aggravating if your garage is connected to a bedroom, kitchen, or living area.
- Higher Maintenance: Garage door openers with chain drives need to be serviced on a regular basis. Keep the drive chain on these pieces of equipment greased, so they continue functioning smoothly.
When Should You Use a Belt Drive Instead of a Chain?
Belt drive garage openers can be used for one-car garages and lightweight doors. They’re ideal when you want to cut down on noise and when you want minimal maintenance. Some people don’t want to be bothered by the frequent maintenance that comes with a chain drive opener.
Also, some belt drive models are wired with Wi-Fi capabilities, so if this is something you feel that you’ll benefit from, you should use a belt drive instead of a chain drive.
Which One Is Easier to Replace: Belt or Chain?
The belt on a belt drive is easier to replace than a chain. This is because the belt is easy to stretch in order to fit onto the gears, and you can usually do this on your own.
If you were to replace a chain, you need to be able to cycle the gears while fitting the chain onto them. This requires at least two people and a lot of patience. And of course, if it’s not installed right, this will cause the chain to slip again. If this happens, you will be back at square one with a garage door opener that’s not working correctly.
Which is More Efficient: Belt or Chain?
Chain drive openers are more efficient. They can provide higher amounts of strength for much less money and thus are frequently selected for larger doors and deserted areas. In deserted areas, it’s better to have a steel carriage for extra protection, which is something that chain drives have no issue lifting.
A chain would outlast a belt with adequate maintenance, albeit the regular use makes a difference. Chain drive openers, like belt drive openers, are available with 1/2 hp to 3/4 hp motors, offering enough power for all of our household garage door models.
Chains have better tensile strength and lifting capability than belts and are commonly utilized on home garage door openers. In some applications, they may also endure longer. The chain is attached with an adjustable clip and powered by a sprocket on top of the motor, similar to how belts are installed.
Heather is a passionate writer who loves anything DIY. Growing up, she learned everything from home repairs to design, and wants to share her tips with you. When she's not writing, she's usually hiking or searching for her next DIY project.
More by Heather Robbins