Do Gutter Guards Work In Heavy Rain? (Find Out Now!)

Heather Robbins
by Heather Robbins
We’re committed to finding, researching, and recommending the best products. We earn commissions from purchases you make using links in our articles. Learn more here
do gutter guards work in heavy rain find out now

Gutters help to safeguard your home from flood damage caused by heavy rainfall. However, gutters can become clogged as well, which is why gutter guards were developed. Do gutter guards, on the other hand, withstand heavy rain?

Gutter guards do not work great in heavy rain, they can obstruct the flow of water into the gutter channel, causing problems during heavy rains. Some designs function better than others, but severe rains will frequently overwhelm the gutter guard, causing stormwater to spill over the gutter’s edge, especially on a large-surface-area roof.

Gutter guards exist in a variety of designs, and some are more effective than others, but the fundamental remains the same. There are also questions about whether gutter guards are appropriate for their intended purpose and whether they would cause problems when it rains heavily.

Do You Need Roofing, Siding, or Gutter Installers?

Get free, zero-commitment quotes from pro contractors near you.

Do Gutter Guards Cause Problems?

By limiting the amount of water that can enter the gutter, gutter guards might cause complications. As a result, it traps moisture in the gutter, allowing smaller debris to enter and detract from the appearance of your home. Gutter overflow can also be caused by poor installation.

Gutter Guards Don’t Stop All Debris

Small openings that allow water to pass through might be blocked by larger material, such as leaves, preventing water from flowing down the gutter.

Gutter guards may not prevent all debris from entering the main gutter channel, and the gutter guard may make it harder to clear the gutters effectively if a clog occurs.

Smaller material, such as pine needles, can get past gutter guards and accumulate in the main gutter channel, causing clogs that must be cleared.

Gutter Guards Can Look Ugly Or Be Poorly Installed

Some gutter guards can be seen from the ground, which might distract from the attractiveness and appearance of your home.

Poor gutter guard installation might cause the gutter guard to fail to work as it should, resulting in water cascading over the gutter rather than falling into it during a severe downpour.

Gutter Guards Can Restrict Water Inflow

The biggest issue with gutter guards is that they hinder water flow into the gutter channel, especially when it rains heavily.

Some gutter guard designs are too tight, preventing sufficient amounts of water from entering, especially during heavy rain. Because of the poor drainage, rainwater may pour over the gutter and fall where you don’t want it to.

Do Leaf Gutter Guards Work In Heavy Rain?

During heavy rains, most leaf gutter guard systems will (somehow) restrict the flow of water. While they may operate effectively at first, when smaller material accumulates in the gutter, they may become less effective at handling strong rain downpours over time. The design does not work well for big amounts of water in several cases.

The efficiency of gutter guards in heavy rain is determined by the gutter guard system’s design and the length of time it has been in place on the gutters.

Gutter Guards Are Best In Low Precipitation Areas

Gutter guards may be an acceptable alternative for you if you do not reside in an area where strong rain showers occur regularly. They may be ineffective from the start if you live in an area where the majority of your rainfall comes in the form of severe showers.

Filters are used in some gutter guards to filter out debris while allowing water to travel through the filter and into the gutter. The water may overflow over the gutter’s edge if the filter does not enable it to pass through quickly enough.

Leaves Are A Problem

Other gutter guard systems include a helmet-style device that directs water into the gutter over the helmet’s lip while directing heavier debris over the gutter’s edge. When the water flow is low, this principle works, but in severe rainfall, rainwater can overshoot and spill over the gutter’s edge.

Is It Normal For Gutters To Overflow In Heavy Rain?

It is unusual for gutters to overflow during a severe downpour. When your gutter overflows during a severe downpour, it usually means there is an issue with your gutter system that has to be addressed.

This could be due to a clog or the gutter being constructed at an angle that does not properly guide the water flow.

Gutters aim to control water flow from the roof and send it away from your property, where it will not cause damage.

Why Home Inspections Are Important

Gutters are made to accommodate the general water flow capacity of the roof based on the type of rain that falls in your area. In a severe storm, standard gutters may struggle to handle the volume of water, but overflowing gutters should be the exception rather than the usual.

If your gutter is overflowing during normal rainfall, you should look at what’s causing it. Water damage to your home’s roof, foundation, and walls can be caused by an overflowing gutter. Fixing your gutters is far less expensive than repairing water damage to your home.

Do You Need Roofing, Siding, or Gutter Installers?

Get free, zero-commitment quotes from pro contractors near you.

What To Consider With Gutter Guards

Leaf and gutter guards may be useful in some situations, but they are not appropriate or worthwhile for all properties. To establish whether a gutter guard is a good fit for your home, you’ll need to assess your specific conditions.

The following are some of the things to think about when it comes to gutter guards:

  • The size of your roof’s surface area. A large-surface-area roof will convey a considerable amount of water to the gutter. Gutter guards are unlikely to be suitable for a big roof surface area, but they may work well on a smaller roof.
  • Gutter guards are not cheap. Installing gutter guards is not inexpensive, so if they are ineffective and detract from the appearance of the home, the expense may not be justified.
  • Gutter guards require regular maintenance. Gutter guards aren’t a one-and-done gutter maintenance solution. Gutter guards must be maintained, and debris that has gotten past the gutter guard must be removed.
  • There are bees and animals that love your gutters. Gutter guards can provide a safe haven in the gutter space for animals that can cause problems, such as bees, wasps, and hornets, as well as tiny birds in some circumstances. These creatures can create nests in the gutter guards’ covers, clogging the gutter.
  • Debris of various sizes. If the material on your roof is from smaller trees, such as pine needles, the gutter guard may not be efficient in keeping the gutter clear.

In general, leaf guards on gutters are not a realistic option for keeping your gutters clear of blockages, and the number of new problems they could cause makes them uneconomical.

Heather Robbins
Heather Robbins

Heather is a passionate writer who loves anything DIY. Growing up, she learned everything from home repairs to design, and wants to share her tips with you. When she's not writing, she's usually hiking or searching for her next DIY project.

More by Heather Robbins