Behr's Sculptor Clay Vs. Benjamin Moore's Revere Pewter

Stacy Randall
by Stacy Randall

Many companies provide paint for your home renovations, but Behr and Benjamin Moore (BM) products are unmatched in quality. These brands’ paints seldom disappoint when showcased in modern houses, focusing on quality and performance. Both Behr and BM’s products are so popular, people instinctively compare them, especially Sculptor Clay (Behr) and Revere Pewter (BM).

Behr Sculptor Clay is a greige with more gray undertones, while Benjamin Moore’s Revere Pewter is a greige with warmer undertones. But both paints are very chameleon-like, changing from looking more gray or more beige depending on the lighting. The preferred color ultimately comes down to the overall look and feel you’re going for in your space.

Undeniably, Revere Pewter and Sculptor Clay are very close on the color chart, but subtle variations exist. Both paints have exceptional quality, are easy to work with, are long-lasting, and comparable in price for smaller interior projects. Understanding both the paints and the differences in these shades is essential in choosing what works best for your design.

Do You Need to Hire a Paint Contractor?

Get free, zero-commitment quotes from pro contractors near you.

An Introduction to Behr and Benjamin Moore Paint

Choosing the perfect color isn’t the only thing to consider when it comes to painting. You also need to pay attention to the paint itself. Paint companies vary in quality, coverage, dry time, and price (to name a few factors).

Therefore, it’s always a good idea to familiarize yourself with the available paint brands. Here’s a closer look at Behr and Benjamin Moore.

Behr vs. Benjamin Moore: Coverage

Behr tends to have a thinner consistency, making it easy to apply and speeding up drying time. You don’t need any special tools, but you’ll need multiple coats to achieve a perfect finish.

Benjamin Moore features a thicker consistency, providing an excellent amount of coverage after its first application. You will likely be able to get a flawless finish after just two coats, three at the most. Plus, this extra consistency, although adding a bit of drying time, doesn’t add that much.

Winner: Benjamin Moore. While both paints offer good coverage, Benjamin Moore nudges slightly ahead thanks to the need for fewer coats. It provides better coverage and takes less time to apply, which means you can get the job done faster.

Behr vs. Benjamin Moore: Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs)

If you’re unfamiliar with Volatile Organic Compounds, you should understand their impact before purchasing a single gallon of paint. These materials contain toxins that damage respiratory systems and pollute the atmosphere.

They’re not only a nuisance to our health – they’re a siphon of our time, too. The more VOCs in a paint product, the less it spreads. This requires extra coats, unnecessary work, and additional expenses.

Nowadays, the top-rated paints incorporate little to no VOCs whatsoever. Not every company has outright ousted them, though.

One such company is none other than Behr. While the amount of VOCs in their products remains negligible, anything above zero can cause problems over time.

Compare that to the purity of Benjamin Moore’s products. Not a single one contains any VOCs to speak of. That means you and your world remain clean and safe, whatever color or product you pick.

Winner: Benjamin Moore. The company’s refusal to incorporate VOCs saves their customers and their environment from any potential regret.

Behr vs. Benjamin Moore: Price

Behr designs budget-friendly products for the average American family. While they limit their stock exclusively to Home Depot, they offer deals and coupons to save even more money.

Benjamin Moore makes premium paints with the price tags to match. Their products tend to double any of Behr’s in price. While they ship their stock to many stores, including their own, they lack discounts and special deals.

Winner: Behr. The cost of Benjamin Moore paints reflects their quality, which could easily extend outside a homeowner’s standard budget. Behr offers affordable paints for any family.

Behr vs. Benjamin Moore: Durability

Here’s the trouble with the financially-friendly Behr brand: their paint needs consistent refreshment. One paint job can only last three to five years at most. You might afford a Behr product once, but ask yourself: can you afford it again in five years?

Not only will it fail in the future, but its quality in the present is debatable at best. Behr paints have an unfortunate reputation, with customers complaining of their thickness. This could create additional challenges while painting.

Benjamin Moore paints replace these headaches with cures to problems before they happen. Their products include a tight film to stop dirt and stains from seeping in and spoiling otherwise perfect paint jobs. Combined with an ability to scrub away imperfections, Benjamin Moore protects your paint for more extended periods.

The piece de resistance? Benjamin Moore’s paints last a decade at the least. You might invest double the money at first, but you only have to replace it half as often.

Winner: Benjamin Moore. The temporary expense provides a long-lasting, high-quality look to any room.

Comparing Behr Sculptor Clay (PPU5-8) And Revere Pewter (HC-172)

Taupey neutral shades that look a little bit gray and a little bit beige have been around for a while. The versatile neutral has become so popular; it even earned its own name–greige.

But, like many other neutral colors, there aren’t just a couple of options. You can find countless shades of greige with various tones. A popular choice for many homeowners is Benjamin Moore’s Revere Pewter.

But, devoted Behr customers and those looking to save a few bucks without sacrificing significant quality sought a comparable match. Enter Behr’s Sculptor Clay. These colors often end up side by side on many tester walls and end up presenting a difficult decision.

This is because they’re so similar yet have just enough differences to make you pause.

Behr Sculptor Clay vs. Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter: Light Reflectance Value

When you pick a paint color at the store, you might be surprised to find it looking different at home. We often forget or forsake the impact even the slightest lighting difference can have on colors. This impact is measured through a paint’s Light Reflectance Value.

The higher a product’s LRV, the brighter each room will appear. High-LRV products help lower electricity bills and lessen the lightning needed per room.

Behr’s Sculptor Clay has an LRV of 55.45, while Benjamin Moore’s Revere Pewter maintains an LRV of 55.51. While not an extreme difference, this does mean that Benjamin Moore’s Revere Pewter shines a tad brighter

Winner: Benjamin Moore’s Revere Pewter. This slight edge over Behr’s Sculptor Clay improves the brightness, but not enough to make a significant difference.

Behr Sculptor Clay vs. Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter: Undertones

While each paint you choose has a primary color, you might notice subtle, other colors peeking through. These underlying colors, known as “undertones,” can drastically affect how they complement other walls and furniture in your room.

Behr’s Sculptor Clay has an orange undertone that helps it to retain an earthy feel. Tones like orange keep your rooms warm, matching with colors like red and yellow.

On the other hand, Benjamin Moore’s Revere Pewter possesses an olive green undertone. Despite green’s typical association with cool colors, this particular tone belongs with other warm colors.

Winner: Tie. What undertone works best for your room depends solely on the other colors you choose.

Revere Pewter vs. Behr Sculptor Clay: Suggested Mood

Any paint has the power to subtly influence the moods of those who witness them. Homeowners can utilize this secret strength to amplify the atmosphere throughout their house.

At first glance, all you would see with either paint is their neutral overtones. These serve to accentuate other colors instead and provide a clean, sleek look themselves. Undertones influence the room, too – more than you might imagine.

Consider the olive green undertones of Benjamin Moore’s Revere Pewter. Green establishes a mellow atmosphere because eyes soften when viewing it. Plus, its desaturated color eases the minds of anyone within its vicinity.

Compare that to the undertones of orange in Behr’s Sculptor Clay. This color brings the same warmth but expresses it through excitement and energy. People in an orange-accented room will feel more willing to move and converse.

Winner: Tie. The strengths and weaknesses of each color lie in how their undertones help or hinder your mission. Pick the color that best accentuates the role each room plays in your house.

Revere Pewter vs. Behr Sculptor Clay: Complementary Colors

Because of the neutral nature of both paints, they pair well with an extensive array of palettes. However, both have distinct colors that complement their specific undertones.

If you’re utilizing Behr’s Sculptor Clay, try using Behr’s Dash of Oregano and Polar Bear. While those will emphasize the paint’s neutral roots, why not consider an accent color? Behr products like Ballet Rose, Ocean Boulevard, and Bay Water bring an extra pop of color to Sculptor Clay.

If you choose Benjamin Moore’s Revere Pewter, combine it with other neutrals like Fog Mist, White Dove, and Amherst Gray. Or, for a more vibrant flair, accent it with hints of coral and teal.

Winner: Tie. As with the undertones, you know what mood you want to set with your palette. The best color is whatever suits your environment most.

Tips For Choosing The Best Paint Color

With thousands of options at your fingertips, picking the optimal colors can stress aspiring designers out. Fear not: you can find the perfect paint without breaking a sweat.

If you already own all of the furniture you’ll use, you have an ideal place to start from. These pieces can act as the basis of your house’s color palette. Select colors that complement your furniture, and you’ll have a unified color scheme before you know it.

You’re not out of luck if you lack furniture. Starting from scratch opens up a world of possibilities – if you know how to start well.

What Do You Want The Color To Do?

Consider this question: what do you want the colors in your house to do? Every color has a role and tone that can drastically alter the feeling of your property.

If you want your space to feel bright and open, plan to purchase whites and cool colors. For a sense of intimacy, pick an earthy palette.

How Do You Want The Color To Make You Feel?

But colors affect more than the sense of space each room has. Each color subconsciously impacts the mood of the people within it.

While each color can have different effects, certain effects are undeniable. A calming room, like a library, could benefit from a soft green. Yellow, on the other hand, stimulates brain activity and could improve offices and studies.

There’s no one right method to picking colors, but determining their role in your home can help. Keep experimenting with different processes until you find the perfect fit for your creativity.


Related Questions

How should I prepare my room for painting?

The thought of repainting can make anyone eager to begin right away. However, to avoid the loss of your time and sanity, there are steps to take beforehand.First up, clear the area of any furniture. While removing furnishings entirely is ideal, it’s not always practical or possible. Cover any furniture left in the room with a cloth that you can afford to trash afterward.Next, those walls could use a good scrub. Dip sponges into a mixture of water and detergent and wash away any spots or stains. Using vacuums or brooms to catch cobwebs and other lingering debris helps prevent future obstructions.Be sure not to clean right before the painting begins. Walls need to dry completely before placing any paint on them, and it can take more time than expected.


When is it better to hire a professional painter?

While painting your property with your own hands feels rewarding, it can also lead to exhaustion and uneven coating. To save yourself the hassle, it’s best to employ a professional in certain circumstances.Most people can carve out the time to paint a single room on its own. A whole house, however, can take weeks that eat away at your already-limited energy. Leave an entire property to the pros.Before painting, ask yourself: what is the condition of these walls? Anyone can coat smooth walls without a problem. Uneven walls or detailed woodwork require a more refined hand.You would think that completely changing the colors of your room would call for a professional. However, the time and materials required for this shift can lead to expensive labor. Instead, hire a professional when choosing to repaint rooms with similar color schemes.

Do You Need to Hire a Paint Contractor?

Get free, zero-commitment quotes from pro contractors near you.

Our Final Take

These two companies have their own unique advantages and drawbacks that benefit specific buyers while compromising others. Ultimately, it depends on the type of room you want to create and your budget to build it.

If you have the extra cash to splurge, Benjamin Moore’s quality surpasses any other. However, those on a budget or who want to redecorate in five years should stick with Behr.

Related Guides

Stacy Randall
Stacy Randall

Stacy Randall is a wife, mother, and freelance writer from NOLA that has always had a love for DIY projects, home organization, and making spaces beautiful. Together with her husband, she has been spending the last several years lovingly renovating her grandparent's former home, making it their own and learning a lot about life along the way.

More by Stacy Randall

Next