Can You Put Charcoal In A Gas Grill? (Find Out Now!)

Can You Put Charcoal in a Gas Grill?

There’s nothing quite like the flavoring of a filet charred on a charcoal grill. What if you have a gas grill instead? Can you put charcoal inside to get the same great taste?

You cannot safely put charcoal in a gas grill unless your device includes a charcoal-specific tray. This is because charcoal creates intense heat and ash debris that can damage your grill’s burner. Alternatives to achieving the same great charcoal taste include using tinfoil prior to cooking and adding extra seasonings. 

If that still doesn’t satisfy your cravings, purchase an actual charcoal grill instead. Usually, they’re much less expensive up-front.

Continue reading to learn if it’s safe to put charcoal in a gas grill and what to do if your grill won’t heat up. Additionally, we’ll cover how to make your gas-grilled protein taste like charcoal!

Let’s get down to business.

Is It Safe to Put Charcoal in a Gas Grill?

Gas grills are designed to run on propane tanks or natural gas. Generally speaking, is it both safe and acceptable to use charcoal instead?

You cannot safely put charcoal in a gas grill because the flames generated by charcoal are too powerful, creating a dangerous and uncontrolled fire hazard. Additionally, the intense heat and ash debris from the charcoal can damage your grill’s burner.

If you try this alternative, you’re likely to end up with an unexpected fire that could potentially cause significant damage to both your grill and your property.

The only exception to this rule is if your gas grill comes with a special charcoal tray.

How Do I Make My Gas-Grilled Food Taste Like Charcoal?

Since this is a no-go, there are several ways you can make your gas-grilled food taste like charcoal (without the risk of burning down your backyard!).

Tips for creating charcoal flavoring in a gas grill include:

  • Using a smoker instead
  • Turning up the heat on your gas grill
  • Putting tin foil on the grill for 30 seconds prior to cooking
  • Adding extra seasonings

Smokers use wood chips to give food a smoky flavor. While it won’t be quite the same taste as charcoal, it adds a more rustic feel than a gas grill.

The easiest and most effective way to get the bite of real charcoal is to turn your grill’s heat up. Propane burns hotter than natural gas, so opt for a propane tank and try increasing the temperature by around 20 degrees Fahrenheit. Just be careful!

Tinfoil is a great way to mimic the effects of cooking over charcoal. Turn on your grill and place a sheet of foil on top for about 30 seconds before you add the food. This will trap the heat and should give you the nice charring effect you’re looking for.

Finally, you can add extra seasonings to your food while you’re grilling it. Garlic powder, onion powder, and pepper are all excellent ways to give an extra kick to your meal. Some companies even have charcoal-inspired seasonings.

Why Won’t My Gas Grill Get Hot?

Here are some of the most common reasons why your gas grill won’t heat up properly:

  • The gas is leaking.
  • Your propane tank is almost empty.
  • The hose is not securely connected to the tank.
  • Your gas grill needs to be repaired.

Sometimes your gas grill just isn’t getting hot enough because there is a gas leak. If you smell something funny, or if your food doesn’t seem to be cooking as quickly as it should, gas is probably escaping from somewhere.

The most probable cause for low heat is the lack of liquid propane. Drive over to the nearest hardware store to purchase a replacement.

Additionally, the hose between the tank and grill may also become loose over time, requiring you to tighten it. It’s important to check that every few uses.

If your gas grill still isn’t heating up, it’s possible you need to call a maintenance specialist. No heat at all, regardless of what you try, indicates the issue may be more serious and beyond simple troubleshooting.

Related Questions

Can you put charcoal in a fireplace?

No, it is not safe to place charcoal into a fireplace, regardless of whether it’s wood-burning or gas.

Burning charcoal releases carbon monoxide and ash, which can be very harmful to the human body (and your home) if ingested or inhaled.

Is charcoal a fossil fuel?

While regular coal is a fossil fuel formed by the Earth millions of years ago, charcoal is not.

Charcoal is made by the partial combustion of wood and other substances. Basically, It’s a dark residue that results from the removal of water and other reactive chemicals from carbonic compounds.

It does not need to be mined and is used mostly for household applications, like cooking.

Why does charcoal turn white?

Charcoal turns white when the pieces are hot on the exterior surface and still cool on the inside. This indicates that they’re heated up and ready to use.

The color change happens because the heat breaks down the large molecules into smaller, more stable molecules. The white shade is caused by small amounts of carbon monoxide and other gases released from the charcoal.

Final Thoughts

Gas grills can be convenient for cooking but are not suitable for putting charcoal inside. If you want to get that authentic smoky flavor from real charcoal, there are a few ways to do it.

You can start with seasoning your meat more aggressively. Some brands even offer a charcoal-flavored option. Using tinfoil to trap heat before throwing your food in a gas grill can also create a charring effect.

When all else fails, you can try increasing the heat on your grill. Just be careful, as propane grills get hotter than natural gas. Make sure you aren’t underneath a covered area or close to something that could catch fire.

If you still aren’t satisfied, consider purchasing a charcoal grill. It’s important to remember that gas grills cost more up-front but are less pricey to maintain over time.

Happy grilling!

Emily Carr

Emily is a copywriter with over five years of experience in crafting content for the home renovation and remodeling industry. She loves house projects, whether it be painting a room or tweaking small design elements to transform a space. Her favorite aesthetic is french modern because of its clean lines and airy feeling! When not writing, Emily loves to travel and check out architectural details all over the world.

Recently Published