Can You Use Traeger Pellets In A Green Mountain Grill? (Find Out Now!)

Stacy Randall
by Stacy Randall

With the summer winding down, many are rushing to get in the last sessions with their outdoor grill before the nights get colder. Many barbecuers who want to cook at a steady temperature swear by the pellet grill. The pellet grill is a modern innovation that drops pellets of your hardwood of choice to maintain a specified temperature.

Two leading companies that make pellet grills are Traeger and Green Mountain, with Green Mountain significantly cheaper than Traeger. However, when it comes to the pellets to fuel your grill, Traeger’s cost less. Luckily, you don’t have to use the matching brand, so you can put Traeger pellets into your Green Mountain grill.

Whether you already have a Green Mountain grill or you’re trying to weigh your options, knowledge is power. But, knowing you have some versatility when it comes to your choice of pellets can undoubtedly make the decision easier.

Do You Need Outdoor Kitchen Installation Services?

Get free, zero-commitment quotes from pro contractors near you.

Choosing a Pellet Grill

When choosing a pellet grill, you have several options, including Traeger and Green Mountain. Both brands are available in most, if not all, parts of the United States. There are a few key differences between the two, namely experience and cost.

Traeger Pellet Grills: A Closer Look

Traeger is the original and gold standard in pellet grills. Joe Traeger, the owner of an Oregon heating company, founded Traeger in 1986, designing and patenting the first pellet grill.

Traeger has been making pellet grills for 35 years. As such, many associate pellet grills with the Traeger brand. Their unparalleled time in the industry makes a guarantee of quality craftsmanship.

Green Mountain Pellet Grills: A Closer Look

However, when Traeger’s patent expired in 2006, many companies rushed to cut out their own corner of the market. Chief among them was Green Mountain, founded by David Baker, a former Traeger enthusiast.

Baker implemented many improvements into his grills. These included a fan to cool down the grill and a higher lid to create more space within the grill. With time, these features would become industry-standard.

Comparing Costs of Traeger and Green Mountain Grills

Traeger and Green Mountain grills are mostly the same, with the same capabilities and features. Some may claim that one is significantly better than the other. However, in the end, it comes down to personal preference over quality.

But, for most, the deciding factor is cost. Traeger grills are much more expensive than ones produced by Green Mountain.

Cost Of Top-Of-The-Line Models

For instance, take a look at the top-of-the-line pellet grills produced by both companies. Green Mountain’s the Peak Prime costs $1,099. On the other hand, Traeger’s Timberline 1300 comes in at a staggering $1,999. Both have the same features and the same cooking space, but the Traeger costs nearly a grand more.

Cost Of Entry Level Models

At the other end of the spectrum, the entry-level offerings of both companies show the same picture. Green Mountain’s cheapest home pellet grill, the Choice Daniel Boone, costs $599.

Traeger’s counterpart, the Pro 575, sits at $799, a 33% increase. Again, both have the same features and similar cooking space, but the Traeger is more expensive by a considerable margin.

Are you just using your grill to feed your family and throw the occasional backyard barbecue? If so, you likely don’t want to break the bank on an appliance you’ll use only a handful of times.

In this case, the choice is simple. The Green Mountain line of pellet grills gives you the most bang for your buck. But, the grill cost isn’t the only consideration; you need to consider the cost of the pellets.

Wood Pellets for Traeger and Green Mountain Grills

Now that you have a pellet grill, you’ll need some pellets to fuel it. First, consider that pellet grills use 1 to 3 pounds of wood pellets per hour. With this in mind, wood pellets could end up costing a king’s ransom over the course of a summer.

While it might be appealing to buy some small brand that offers wood pellets for pennies on the dime, don’t. You might not know what goes into those wood pellets.

The wood might have pesticides or other dangerous chemicals or potentially isn’t even wood. As a result, the recommendation is to buy wood pellets from a reputable company, like those making pellet grills.

You Don’t Have To Match Pellets To Grill

First, you do not need to buy wood pellets from the same company that made your pellet grill. You can use Green Mountain pellets in your Traeger or vice-versa. While the companies may claim that their grills work best with their proprietary grill, this, quite simply, isn’t true.

This is just another effort to secure your long-term business. However, since Traeger invented the pellet grill, by extension, they created the wood pellets. Therefore, many feel they could be more trustworthy or might have a marginally better product.

As such, the choice between Traeger and Green Mountain pellets comes down to personal preference, availability, and cost.

Why Use Traeger Pellets In A Green Mountain Grill?

Previously, it was established that the most economical choice for pellet grills is one produced by Green Mountain. However, for pellets, the opposite is true.

Pellet Cost

First, consider the actual cost of the wood pellets. Both Green Mountain and Traeger have bags for around $20.

The difference? Traeger’s $20 bag gives you 20 pounds of wood pellets. Green Mountain’s bargain bag is a mere 8 pounds in weight.

Pellet Availability

The second factor to consider is the availability of the pellets. Traeger sells their pellets online, both on their website and on Amazon. Green Mountain has a very small stock on Amazon that is often depleted.

Your only other option is a visit to an affiliated store, which is often located far away from major cities. True, that drive to the store might not be bad one time when you buy the grill. However, if you’re making the trip multiple times in a month, it adds up quickly.

Again, if you’re just an ordinary person and not a popular restaurant, the choice is clear. It is much better for your wallet if you go with the cheaper and easier option. In this case, that would be Traeger’s wood pellets.

Do You Need Outdoor Kitchen Installation Services?

Get free, zero-commitment quotes from pro contractors near you.

Related Questions

Can you use Pit Boss pellets in a Traeger grill?

Like putting Traeger pellets in a Green Mountain grill, the brands don’t have to match up. Therefore, you can put Pit Boss pellets in a Traeger grill and vice versa. The pellet shape is relatively similar, and the produced flavors are comparable. You should always expect very minimal differences, but they wouldn’t be significant enough to make a big impact. 

Can you make your own Traeger pellets?

If you don’t want to buy pellets, you could always attempt making some at home. But, you need a pellet mill to do so, and they can cost anywhere from $450 to over $3,000. You need to choose sawdust from a hardwood that is a good match for barbecue, like mesquite, hickory, or applewood. To avoid contaminating food, you also need to ensure the wood is clean and free of insecticides or chemicals. Place a plastic bucket below the mill’s chute and wait for the mill to heat up. Put small batches of sawdust into the hopper and let them cool in the bucket. If you don’t use the pellets right away, store them in a sealed bag in a dry location.

Stacy Randall
Stacy Randall

Stacy Randall is a wife, mother, and freelance writer from NOLA that has always had a love for DIY projects, home organization, and making spaces beautiful. Together with her husband, she has been spending the last several years lovingly renovating her grandparent's former home, making it their own and learning a lot about life along the way.

More by Stacy Randall