2-Way Vs. 3-Way Speakers For A Home Theater: Which Is Better?
Shopping for a home theater system can be confusing on several different levels. A basic understanding of how the home theater system work is essential to the decision. Fundamental to this understanding is a clear idea of the advantages and disadvantages of 2-way and 3-way speakers.
2-way speakers systems deliver sound through two speakers that operate in two frequency ranges. 3-way speaker systems further divide the sound ranges. 3-way speaker systems are not necessarily better than 2-way speaker systems. The speakers’ location, the equipment driving the speakers, and the speakers’ quality all figure into the quality of the sound that is delivered.
There are several factors to be considered when choosing speakers for your home theater system. Among these factors you must consider are:
- The speakers themselves
- Where you are using the home theater and speakers
- The quality of the amplifier/receiver driving the speakers
The Elements of Sound Reproduction
Sound reproduction is somewhat of a mystery for most people. To get a better grasp of 2-way versus 3-way speakers, some fundamental knowledge of how speakers reproduce sounds is necessary. On the surface, the concepts are simple. However, the underlying truth can get complicated.
Frequencies – The Range of Sounds
Sound ranges in frequency across a wide band. Some are too high for the human ear to detect. Some are so low that we don’t hear them, but we may feel them as vibrations. Our ears can detect the range of frequencies that are of interest when discussing home theater systems.
How Speakers Reproduce Sounds
Speakers convert electrical signals to mechanical movement. As the electrical signals from an amplifier arrive in the speaker, the signals cause the speaker’s cone to move back and forth. The movement of the speaker cone produces vibrations that we hear as sound.
Reproducing the entire range of frequencies with a single speaker is the problem. Different frequency ranges require different speaker configurations to reproduce the sounds accurately. This need for different speaker configurations is the basis for 2-way and 3-way speaker systems
The 2-way System – Two Frequency Ranges
2-way speaker system used electronic systems in the amplifier or receiver to separate the range of sounds. These two frequency ranges feed speakers designed to reproduce the sound in those frequency ranges more accurately.
In practice, there is some crossover in the frequency ranges delivered to the two speakers. This crossover creates a fuller and richer sound in the mid-frequency ranges. This crossover in frequencies often results in more pleasing sound reproduction.
3-way Speakers – Is More Better?
Theoretically, splitting the sound frequencies into more ranges creates better sound reproduction. However, this is not often the case. 3-way speaker systems typically split the higher frequency range of a 2-way speaker system. The quality of the sound reproduction is a function of the quality of the speakers.
Many so-called three-way speaker systems use the same speaker components for the two upper-frequency bands. This speaker configuration doesn’t add materially to the quality of the upper-frequency sound reproduction. The speaker design must match the frequency range of the signals sent to the speaker.
The Cross-Over Problem – When Too Much is More than Enough
Another problem often seen in 3-way speaker systems is crossover interference. The more the system splits the frequency ranges, the more crossover that occurs between the different speakers. This crossover interference can cause the reproduced sound to degrade enough to be heard.
The solution to the crossover interference problem is not better speakers. The solution is better crossover filters. Higher-end amplifiers and receivers will incorporate crossover filters to eliminate as much of this crossover interference as possible.
The Anatomy of a 2-Way Speaker
A close examination of a 2-way speaker system can tell you a lot about the sound reproduction quality you can expect. There are several things to consider when looking at a 2-way speaker.
- First, you should note that a 2-way speaker system should have two speakers. If the speaker box doesn’t contain two distinct and separate speakers, it is not a 2-way speaker system.
- The speakers should be of different sizes. One of the speakers is larger and drives the lower frequencies. This larger speaker is called the woofer. The second and smaller speaker drives the upper-frequency range and is called the tweeter.
- The speaker enclosure may separate the two speakers. This separation is often an attempt to limit crossover or interference between the speakers.
Inside a True Three-Way Speaker – A Trio of Sound Drivers
As you might expect, a true three-way speaker system has three distinct speakers in the enclosure. Often, speakers advertised as 3-way use the same speakers to drive the two upper-frequency ranges. A true 3-way speaker should have drivers tuned to the frequency range they serve.
The three speakers in a 3-way speaker system use a large speaker called the woofer to drive the lower frequency sounds. A smaller speaker, termed a mid-range or sub-woofer, drives the frequencies between the woofer and the tweeter. The smallest speaker called a tweeter drives the upper range frequencies.
Three speakers, tuned for the frequencies they drive, should deliver cleaner and clearer sound reproduction. The problem occurs when the crossover between the frequencies causes interference in the sound itself.
The Major Considerations of Speaker Selection
There are several considerations to be made when selecting speakers for your home theater system. One of these factors is the quality of the speakers themselves. However, the amplifier/receiver driving the speakers can have almost as much influence on the speakers’ sound reproduction quality.
The size and layout of the room where you locate your home theater system are important. The room’s layout and size can affect the quality of the sound you hear from your system.
Start with the Home Theater System
The better the cross0ver filters in your home theater system, the better the sound reproduction. Your home theater system must match your speaker selection. A home theater system designed for driving a 2-way speaker system can’t adequately drive a 3-way speaker.
For the best sound reproduction from your home theater system, look for an amplifier/receiver that allows you to tune the crossover filters manually. Manual tuning allows you to compensate for other factors such as the speaker design or the room’s layout.
Consider the Speakers
The box housing your speakers can have a great effect on the quality of the sound. The construction and design of the speaker housing are almost as important as the quality of the speakers.
Poorly designed and constructed speaker housings can create more problems with sound reproduction. A bad design can create distortion or crossover interference with the speakers. Well-designed speaker housings may isolate woofers from the mid-range and tweeters and deliver the sound through separate physical channels.
In many cases, the cost of your speakers will be more than the cost of the balance of your home theater system. Skimping on your speakers will almost always result in less than satisfying sound from your home theater system.
Finding a Good Location – Fitting your Home Theater Sound System to Your Room
As with real estate, a home theater is all about location. The room’s configuration, the room size, and the furnishings in the room all affect the quality of the sound reproduced by the speakers. Planning your room and your home theater sound system must go hand in hand to get the best results.
Room Size – Space is Key
Look critically at the room where you want to put your home theater sound system. You should make a note of the following things about the room.
- The Overall Size of the Room – Room size is a factor in choosing your speakers and your home theater sound system. The larger the room, the more you may suffer interference or echo. Larger rooms also take greater care with speaker placement than smaller rooms. Larger rooms will benefit from a 3-way speaker system
- Ceiling Height – In general, a higher ceiling delivers better sound. Higher ceilings create less speaker bounce and can enhance sound reproduction. Rooms with higher ceilings typically do better with good 3-way speaker systems.
What’s in The Room?
The furnishings of your home theater room also play into the choice of 2-way or 3-way speakers. Overall, these factors may influence your decision.
- Carpet tends to soften sound reproduction. If your home theater room has thick pile carpet, consider choosing 3-way speakers that provide a richer high-frequency response range.
- Large, overstuffed furniture can have the same effect. 3-way speakers that deliver more intense upper-frequency sounds can overcome this sound deadening effect.
Who’s Watching and What do You Watch?
Who spends most of the time using your home theater? Consider some of these options when choosing a 2-way or 3-way speaker system.
- If the home theater system’s primary users are children, a 2-way speaker system is probably more than adequate.
- If you use your home theater room for entertaining while watching TV, a 3-way speaker system may be more appropriate.
- The content you watch is a consideration. Feature movies, especially action-adventure flicks, often come with enhanced soundtracks that reproduce better on a 3-way speaker system. Video gaming is usually served quite well with 2-way speaker systems.
The Quality of Sound Can Affect the Quality of Your Experience
Enjoying a home theater system is as much about the experience as it is about the content. Sound is an important aspect of many movies and other entertainment events. To get the most from your home theater system, you must choose the right speaker system. Consider all the factors we have discussed when deciding between 2-way and 3-way speakers for your home entertainment system.
Dennis is a retired firefighter with an extensive background in construction, home improvement, and remodeling. He worked in the trades part-time while serving as an active firefighter. On his retirement, he started a remodeling and home repair business, which he ran for several years.
More by Dennis Howard